Scottie's Workshop: a ReviewAn independent customer review of Scottie Sharpe’s Scottie’s Workshop in Murphys, California

Source material

Supporting documents

The invoice, agreement, email exchanges, photographs, and videos supporting my review.

Documents

Read the invoice, combined agreement, and correspondence below. The email PDFs contain the exchanges in context, including my messages.

Sidecar photographs

Photographs

Four photographs of the sidecar. Click any image for full size.

Rear view of the BMW and Steib sidecar leaning toward one another
This is dangerous and set up incorrectly, falling inward just 37 miles in. View full size ↗
Sidecar suspension attachment beside scraped and damaged bodywork
The suspension-failure area and resulting damage, documented after the reported failure at approximately 83 miles. View full size ↗
Project background & chronology

Why I sent it to Scottie’s

My motorcycle is a 1967 BMW R 60/2 with a Steib S500 sidecar. Following an initial consultation, I chose Scottie’s Workshop in Murphys, California, for substantial restoration work. I understood that an old motorcycle would continue to need maintenance.

What mattered to me was getting it back competently assembled and functioning as agreed. The workshop’s “Revival Service” language was part of that expectation. The agreement states: “Motorcycles completing the Revival Service will ride and function perfectly but will retain their ‘patina’.” Read the agreement, page 3 ↗ My total payment for the restoration was $33,254.19.

From delivery to the first failures

  1. The motorcycle reaches the workshop

    I delivered the BMW and sidecar. The written completion timeframe was 12–14 months.

  2. The wait extends

    I repeatedly sought updates and completion dates. As the project ran beyond the original timeframe, the uncertainty became a major source of frustration.

  3. No forecast for completion

    In an email, Scottie said he did not provide speculative restoration completion dates.

  4. The motorcycle comes home

    The motorcycle returned after approximately 20½ months.

  5. Brake failure and further inspection

    The mechanical findings and videos are collected below.

  6. The sidecar suspension failed

    I reported further sidecar damage.

  7. Five more problems noticed

    Sidecar and turn-signal light failures, unsecured rear taillight wires, tire-to-fender contact, and erratic ignition-key operation. See the issues and video links ↗

  8. Work and questions remain

    I spent more than 40 hours researching, adjusting, sourcing parts, and seeking help. Shifting trouble and sidecar damage remained unresolved in that account.

Read the public account

The original public discussions are available below.

Forum replies represent their authors’ views. They are not independent verification of the mechanical causes described here. This site focuses on my motorcycle and experience.

Read the original Reddit account and discussion ↗

Read the Vintage BMW forum discussion ↗

The records are supplied as source material. My account distinguishes what I observed from suspected causes and from the workshop’s position. No agency finding or court judgment is presented here.

Back to the review →